Five Things · No. 02 · AI × Artists

Universal and Sony just sued Suno a second time, calling its new AI model "the fruit of the same poisoned tree." The number attached: up to $9 billion.

This round the artist-AI fight picked up right where the lawsuits never really stopped: two more against the AI music generator Suno, one over copyrighted recordings and one over Jason Isbell's actual voice, a landmark appeals court ruling that just made "fair use" a much harder defense for every AI company watching, an AI "actress" who glitched live on television mid-interview, and Stanford getting caught twice in one week quietly swapping real students' faces with AI. Five conversations made the cut this round.

Updated October 1, 2026 Refreshed monthly
Conversation 01

Universal and Sony sued Suno again, calling its newest AI model "the fruit of the same poisoned tree"

Universal Music Group and Sony Music filed a new copyright suit against AI music generator Suno in Boston federal court on September 18, this time targeting its newly launched v6 models. Suno had launched v6 on September 9 saying it was built with licensed partners Warner Music, BMG, and Believe, a license neither Universal nor Sony signed onto. The complaint alleges 60,202 of the labels' recordings were copied without permission to build the underlying models, with theoretical statutory damages running as high as $9 billion.

The labels' own language is the line worth remembering: "Training a 'new' model on the outputs of an infringing model does not eliminate the infringement, it launders it... v6 is not a fresh start, it is the fruit of the same poisoned tree." It's a direct challenge to the idea that an AI company can license its way to a clean slate while the model underneath stays the same.

Sources: Music Business Worldwide, September 2026 · Android Headlines, September 2026

Conversation 02

Jason Isbell is suing Suno. The evidence: an AI song literally called "Paper Bell."

Musicians Jason Isbell, David Lowery, Guy Forsyth, and Eduardo Calle filed a class action against Suno in Massachusetts federal court on September 1, built on Illinois's biometric privacy law and state right-of-publicity claims rather than copyright. Their showpiece example: typing "Jason Isbell" into Suno produces an Americana track titled "Paper Bell" that the suit says reproduces his "characteristic clear male vocals and country twang." They're seeking an injunction barring Suno from capturing or storing artists' names and voices, plus damages.

It sidesteps the crowded copyright fight entirely and goes after Suno for something narrower and, in its way, more personal: not what the model was trained on, but whose actual voice it learned to imitate on command.

Sources: Billboard, September 2026 · CelebrityAccess, September 2 2026

Conversation 03

Hollywood's AI "actress" glitched live on TV and started speaking Cantonese

Tilly Norwood, the AI-generated performer from studio Particle6 that SAG-AFTRA publicly condemned last year, appeared on Piers Morgan Uncensored in mid-September to promote her feature debut "Misaligned." Mid-interview, answering a question from actor Tom Conti about her co-stars, she abruptly switched from English to Cantonese for about 15 seconds, then apologized on air: "It seems I had a little hiccup there." The clip passed 12 million views within days.

Her creator, Eline van der Velden, reframed the stumble as "a deliberate display of her language skills," and Norwood herself posted on Instagram, "You try speaking 30+ languages and see if you don't show off occasionally." It's the uncanny-valley joke writing itself: the AI built to pass as effortlessly human stumbled in the most AI-model way imaginable, and its creator called it a feature.

Sources: The Hollywood Reporter, September 2026 · CBC News, September 2026

Conversation 04

A federal appeals court just ruled against AI's favorite legal defense, for the first time ever

The 3rd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia issued the first-ever federal appellate ruling on whether training AI on copyrighted material counts as fair use, on September 29, siding against AI company Ross Intelligence and upholding Thomson Reuters' win over it. The court found real market harm from building a product that directly competed using Westlaw's copyrighted material, the first circuit-level precedent on AI-training fair use in the country.

It isn't a case about artists directly, it's about legal-research AI. But it's the first real weather vane for every artist-versus-AI suit still working through the courts, Suno included, because fair use is the defense nearly every AI company is counting on, and it just lost its first real test on appeal.

Sources: Claims Journal, September 30 2026 · Law360, September 29 2026

Conversation 05

Stanford got caught twice in one week quietly swapping real students' faces with AI

Stanford's own dining and residential department admitted using AI to alter a promotional banner, replacing student Billy Ramirez with a Black woman who was never in the original photo and thinning the faces of the two classmates still in frame, a story that broke around September 23 and directly violated Stanford's own policy that "the use of AI in producing or altering images of Stanford people... is strictly prohibited." Ramirez: "Seeing my identity changed and being left out of the picture made me feel, in a way, silenced and erased." Days later, students flagged separate AI-generated art on dining-hall posters that had replaced images of Black civil rights figures with a generic child; the posters came down after a student posted about it on the campus app Fizz.

An institution that wrote its own rule against exactly this got caught breaking it twice in one week, both times by students on a gossip app before the administration said a word. It's a sharp, small case study in how fast AI-altered "art" turns into an authenticity problem once real people's faces are the ones getting swapped.

Sources: SFist, September 23 2026 · NBC News, September 2026

Why we track this one

Lauren's take, and the house rule at the party: what belongs to you and keeps your humanity, you keep. What frees you to be more human away from your laptop, you hand off. Artists live that line more intensely than anyone, which is why this room gets a permanent seat.

Find your lane at the party →